I still remember my first day walking into a class with no plan, no names, and 25 curious faces watching me figure it out. It felt like flying a plane right after takeoff.
If you’ve had that feeling too, this guide will help.
We’ll go through smart substitute teacher strategies, simple classroom management tricks, and how to stay flexible without feeling lost. You’ll also get easy ways to connect with students, adapt fast, and stay in control even when there’s no plan waiting for you.
On your first day, start with the basics: smile, make eye contact, and set a calm tone. Don’t worry about delivering a perfect lesson. Focus on creating a space where learning can happen.
Ready to make it happen in real life? Let’s begin.
Substitute Teacher Strategies That Actually Work
You’re standing at the door with a class list, a marker, and a room full of students who’ve never seen you before. What you do in the next few minutes matters more than most people realise. The way you enter the classroom can affect the entire day, especially if it’s your first time in the classroom.

So, you need to acquire proper substitute teacher strategies that are simple, flexible, and work at any grade level. Here you go.
- Greet students as they enter
A calm “Hi, I’m Mr Green” or “Welcome in, Year 6” can change the tone positively before the day even begins. When students hear their name and see a friendly face, they’re more likely to respond with respect. You can try using a quick get-to-know-you prompt like “What’s your favourite snack?” to start building rapport. - Write your name and the day’s plan on the board
This helps students feel grounded. Use short, clear headings like “Reading, Maths, Free Writing” so they know what’s coming. For visual learners, draw simple icons beside each task. If your class includes special education students, this kind of visual support can make a big impact on the students. - Start with one calm, clear rule
A phrase like “We listen while others are speaking” works across classrooms. Then model it by waiting your turn and listening fully when students talk. It sets a tone of mutual respect. When someone forgets, quietly point back to the rule. It’s a teaching tip that works with younger students and older ones alike. - Assign simple classroom jobs
Students love feeling helpful. Ask someone to hand out books, another to track time, or a third to collect pencils. Jobs create small pockets of ownership and reduce downtime. Bonus Tip: Students who usually drift off-task often engage more when they have something meaningful to do. - Leave a thoughtful note
A few sentences can make a teacher’s return much easier. Mention which students helped, what work was completed, and anything unusual that came up. If you can, leave specific praise: “Jayden helped clean up without being asked.” These notes also show school administrators that you handled the day with care.
Even if you’re only there for one day, these teaching strategies help students feel supported and help you teach with calm confidence.
How to Handle Behaviour Without Becoming the Enemy
Classroom behaviour often changes the moment a substitute teacher enters. Students may act differently because their regular routine feels disrupted. They’re not reacting to you personally, but to the change in structure. Bringing a steady presence helps the class settle and gives you a solid base to teach from.
So, start by asking students how the day normally begins. Most will happily tell you. That one question gives you a sense of flow and shows students that their experience matters. You’ll start earning respect just by being open to their input.
Instead of raising your voice to cut through the noise, use a calm cue. Try a hand signal, a quiet countdown, or even a simple “Let’s bring it back.” These tools support classroom management without creating conflict. They also cut down the need to repeat yourself.
Here’s a quick guide for common situations:
Challenge | Response That Helps |
Talking over you | Pause, look toward the student, wait silently |
Side conversations | Quietly check in with a question or eye contact |
Pushback or resistance | Offer a clear choice between two acceptable actions |
Older students appreciate subtlety. Keep your tone calm and handle redirection privately when possible. It protects their confidence and keeps the class focused.

Your teaching style plays a part, too. Some teachers work best with a firm structure, while others prefer a more flexible flow. What matters most is being consistent. Clear expectations help students feel safe and ready to learn.
Behaviour management is about understanding what’s behind the disruption. Are they confused? Bored? Struggling? When you respond with insight instead of frustration, you support the learning process, not just discipline.
When the classroom feels steady, students can get back to learning. And you can get back to teaching with confidence.
Got No Lesson Plan? Try These On-the-Spot Fixes
Imagine you walk into the classroom. The bell rings. The desk is clean, the whiteboard is blank, and there’s no sign of today’s lesson plans. It’s a moment every substitute teacher faces at some point, and it doesn’t need to throw off the day. There are easy ways to teach, engage, and help students stay focused, even when you’re working from scratch.
Here are some flexible activities that work across grade levels:
- “What If” class discussion
Ask something like, “What if school started at 1 pm?” Let students take turns answering. This encourages participation and gets them talking and thinking. It works well as group work and helps ease them into the day. - Silent Sketch Time
Have students draw a scene from their favourite story, subject, or recent topic. Pair it with graphic organisers for structure or use it to introduce new concepts. This also supports special education students who benefit from visual supports. - Quick teach-backs
Ask students to explain something they’ve recently learned. This reveals where they’re confident or where more review is needed. It also reinforces the learning process through peer expression. - Creative writing challenge
Use prompts like, “Write about a time something unexpected happened.” It helps students practise storytelling and builds confidence in expressing ideas.
If you’re unsure what’s been covered in this classroom, ask other teachers nearby. They may offer useful context or spare lesson plans that align with the current topic.
Teaching tip: Keep a few simple lesson plans in your bag. Think word games, short writing tasks, or single-sheet activities that work across subjects. According to the Education Endowment Foundation, short, structured tasks like these can improve memory and focus, even with older students.
When the plans are missing, you’re still in charge. These quick strategies help students stay on track and allow you to teach with confidence.
Encourage Students to Take Part and Shine
One of the best ways to help your students is by motivating them to take part in various activities. When you encourage students to take part early on, it opens the door to stronger engagement and smoother classroom behaviour. These three approaches help keep students involved, motivated, and confident.

Ask a question they can’t get wrong
Start the day with something simple like, “What’s your favourite thing about weekends?” Based on our firsthand experience, we can say that most students can answer such comforting questions without feeling pressure. It builds connections and gives even quiet students a chance to join in. Questions like this create early participation without any risk of being wrong.
Let them show what they know in different ways
Not every student wants to write a full paragraph. Some would rather draw, speak, or sort ideas using graphic organisers. When you offer options like these, it helps more students engage fully in their own learning. It also supports students with special needs who benefit from clear visuals and low-pressure tasks.
Notice the small stuff
When a student quietly helps someone or shows care for the classroom, mention it. These moments often go unrecognised, but they say a lot about how students interact with each other. Noticing those details encourages more participation and positive behaviour throughout the day.
As per our expertise, these methods help students feel confident, included, and more willing to learn. They also give you more ways to support everyone in the room.
Student Feedback Isn’t Just for Full-Time Teachers
Even if you’re only covering for a day, asking for student feedback can make a positive impact on you. It shows that you care about their experience and gives you insight into how your approach is landing. These moments of reflection help students recognise their own learning, and they help you teach better each time.
Try these quick, low-pressure options before the end of the day:
- Ask for a thumbs-up or thumbs-down after each activity
- Let students write one sentence: “What I liked most today”
- Place a slip of paper on desks asking, “What’s one thing I’d change?”
These small habits support classroom engagement and build trust. They also give you a chance to adjust your teaching style in ways that help students feel more included and more involved.
You don’t need to overthink the process. Even five minutes at the end of the day can lead to insights that improve your next visit. Plus, students feel more valued when they see that their opinions have an impact.
Experienced agencies like OTJR Online, which have helped thousands of teachers find their ideal roles across London, understand how important it is to gather honest feedback. It’s one of the ways good substitute teachers stand out and grow in their careers.
Taking a moment to ask what worked and what didn’t shows students you’re there to make the day better for them, not just get through it.

How to Turn One Day Into the Next Opportunity
A single day as a substitute teacher can open more doors. If you show up prepared, communicate well, and help students stay on track, people notice. Our thorough assessment revealed that teachers remember the ones who handled things calmly. School administrators remember who left the room clean and the lesson notes detailed. These things matter.
Before you leave, take a moment to organise the desk, return materials, and check in with the front office. A quick thank-you goes a long way. If you enjoyed the experience, speak with other teachers or the deputy head about future needs. Even if you’re working across different grade levels, building these relationships helps create opportunities for more consistent work.
Substitute teachers who stand out don’t just follow lesson plans. They bring positive energy and use practical teaching strategies that fit the moment. That kind of presence makes you a welcome part of the school community.
If you’re looking to turn short-term work into something more, contact OTJR Online to get quick help. With over 20 years of experience helping educators find long-term roles, they understand the value of professionalism and reliability in education.